The Death of the Cervical Collar?

Those fantastic Vikings over at one of my favourite FOAMed sites, ScanCrit have been rampaging through the dogma of cervical collars for some time, and now it seems the campaign is coming to a head:

Bergen EMS will no longer apply c-collars to patients

This is a pretty big move; c-collars have been part of the fundamentals of EMS since the birth of the specialty despite an almost complete lack of evidence of any benefit.

Many studies have been carried out on cadavers and healthy volunteers and have shown that spinal immobilization may actually increase distraction between vertebrae, increase ICP, impair airway management, impair ventilation, act as a fulcrum which increases spine movement on transfer, cause pressure sores and even if well fitted still allow for 30 degrees of movement in any plane!

As for studies showing the benefit, they are… 

 

The lack of evidence for benefit along with the increasing evidence of harm has been the impetus for this move and Bergen EMS are to be applauded for taking the initiative.  I predict there will be howls of protest coming from the international EMS community, so I will be watching with interest to see how they get on.  Nonetheless I think it is the sensible thing to do.  With nothing but hypothetical benefits and an increasing weight of evidence of harm, the right thing to do is to completely re-evaluate practice.

So when can we expect to see a change to our practice?  I predict: never.  Sadly the dogma of c-collars for all is very, very well embedded in our culture, handed down from generation to generation as holy sacrament, never to be questioned.  I will therefore continue my practice of using c-collars carefully where required and the spine-board never (except as an extrication device)

For more information on the general badness of cervical collars, check out ScanCrits other post here and head over to Sydney HEMS site for a three part series here, here and here as well as posts on the futility of collars in penetrating and ballistic neck injuries.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Trauma and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to The Death of the Cervical Collar?

  1. rfdsdoc says:

    Reblogged this on PHARM and commented:
    let the debate begin!

  2. medest118 says:

    Reblogged this on MEDEST and commented:
    Immobilizzazione spinale sul territorio? U contributo importante viene dalla Norvegia. Aperto dibattito…..

  3. Pingback: Collier cervical | thoracotomie

  4. James Oz says:

    Thank god. Bring it on.

  5. Pingback: JC: Self extrication vs. assisted extrication. St.Emlyn's - St.Emlyn's

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s